The search term must be at least 3 characters long. The Witcher 2 To kill or not to kill, the pig named Henselt? Steamisbetter Steamisbetter Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View profile View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friends Invite to friends Accept invitation Accept invitation Pending invitation You can't chat with this user due to their or your privacy settings. You can't chat with this user because you have blocked him.
You can't invite this user because you have blocked him. Posted August 07, I let him go. But what happens if you kill him? If you kill him, dialogue changes during Radovid meet. In 3 he somehow dies anyway, so you should kill him, to at least satisfy yourself by revenge!
Radovid makes you tell him how this happened. You can use persuasion but if you try to hide the truth from him Henselt was murdered fails. You can take the fall instead of Roche, though but Roche doesn't have any consequences. Save game before that dialogue, if you replay, because even telling the truth fails, sometimes. You can't tell him and convince him with the "I wasn't there", line. ThePro ThePro Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable.
Posted August 13, The question isn't really whether or not to kill Henselt, it's whether to have Geralt stop Roche from killing Henselt. Triss survives anyways. Dethmold dies horribly. He claims he is merely holding it as a protectorate, but it essentially becomes part of his dominion, and Anais will likely never be Queen.
Roche takes up the Redanian Red. Roche remains a Blue Stripe. The Lodge retains a strong member. The realm of the Pontar Valley retains its leader, despite being influenced by the Lodge. However, the last dragon in the world is likely dead, and the Pontar Valley lacks a leader. The Pontar Valley stays strong and is truly free of outside control. Geralt earns the gratitude of Saskia and Iorveth alike. The School of the Viper may spring up as a powerful tool against the Wild Hunt, or Nilfgaard may try to use Letho more in the future.
Letho and Geralt settle their debt of friendship and blood. The School of the Viper is likely doomed and Nilfgaard loses a potential pawn. Source link [forums. Thanks for the guide, it's good to know how events would've unfolded if I made different decisions, and by the looks of it the outcome I got is the worst for both Temeria and the north in general.
God damn it Geralt! Stygian 30 Mar am. StormCrow 15 Sep, pm. I've only played through the game once and I am almost sorry I read this. Very thorough. SnitchyBoi 20 Apr, am.
Thank you very much for making this! Mendax 14 Apr, pm. Pri3st 10 Mar, pm. I've played it both ways; and having done so, I won't play letting Roche kill Henselt again.
Henselt himself is beyond pardon. His crimes have been enumerated and don't require repetition. If anyone deserves to die, he does. There are three reasons I can think of why he should not, but only one of those is telling. There is the argument that it is always wrong to murder a king. I don't buy it. Its support is in the anachronistic concept of the divine right of kings.
Quite the contrary: the duty of the people to oust a tyrant by all necessary force has been current IRL at least since Cicero De Officiis , which is also the source of the very relevant notion of "lesser evil". There is the argument that it is undesirable, in general and especially at present, to remove a strong war leader and plunge yet a third Northern Kingdom into anarchy. That would have carried more weight if Henselt were not already in bed with Nilfgaard.
Far from ousting a strong and valuable leader, killing Henselt is the punishment due a traitor, the same punishment he exacted from Sabrina. Divine right and global politics are lost on Geralt anyway. Geralt's loyalty is to his friends, even including Roche, and he knows Roche is a hothead who would do something he would end up regretting. He's been through this with Roche time and again. He knows Roche should not kill Henselt, because Roche will be hurt by his own guilty knowledge maybe even to the point of losing confidence in his own ability to command.
So he does what he's done for his friend before, talking Roche out of a rash and self-destructive act. CostinRaz Banned 17 Oct 14, CostinRaz Banned 19 Oct 14, I do both depending on how i play the game at the time and as there is no option for both i can not vote.
Similar threads. Lets guess the December cards. Oct 6, Improve the Spoiler Tab. Aug 2, Cyberpsycho Lex Talionis dies no matter what [Bug]. Sep 3, Aug 21,
0コメント